Businesses are free to agree the price of goods or services unless a statutory exception applies. Constitutional business freedom and private autonomy allow them to organise activities on their own responsibility. In collecting tax, the authority must protect those rights and act only within powers granted by law.

It must therefore generally accept the agreed price and cannot adjust transaction value simply to assess additional tax. The Supreme Court has emphasised that prices may be above or below market value. Whether an expense is business-related cannot be determined merely by describing the price as unreasonable, economically unjustified or not indispensable.

Price adjustment and reliance on market value are permitted only where the law provides. Otherwise, the question is whether the goods or services themselves relate to the business. Additional assessment requires statutory conditions, commonly that the parties are related.

For income tax, section 50(4) of the Income Tax Act addresses transfer pricing. If the price between a company and a related person differs from comparable independent transactions, the authority may use the arm's-length value. Tax applies to income the company would have received, or expenses it would have avoided, at market value.

Where parties are unrelated, the excess price cannot generally be taxed as a non-business expense merely for being excessive. Case law does not recognise a concept of a partial gift for this purpose. In exceptional circumstances, even an interest-free loan may be business-related where the lender obtains another benefit, such as a share of a joint project's profits or discounts.

For VAT, section 12(14) of the Value Added Tax Act sets adjustment conditions. Related-party supplies can be valued at market price where a below-market buyer lacks full input VAT deduction, or an above-market seller lacks it. In the first case, the buyer seeks to reduce its tax cost; in the second, the seller seeks a greater taxable proportion and input deduction. Where the buyer can deduct the full amount, adjustment would not create additional state revenue.

The Supreme Court has explained that inter-business transactions generally create no final tax burden where output VAT corresponds to the buyer's input deduction. The article also discusses this correspondence for sham or concealed transactions. If the special statutory conditions are absent, transaction value cannot be adjusted. There are strong arguments that the general economic interpretation rule in section 84 of the Taxation Act cannot circumvent a special rule simply because the price differs substantially from market value. Otherwise, the special rule would lose its purpose and legal certainty would suffer.

Businesses must be allowed to transact and take commercial risks using their judgment. An apparently low or high price may, in context, secure a long-term benefit or avoid loss. The tax authority should not intervene arbitrarily and should generally accept the agreed price.

MAGILEX← Back to all articles