In its decision of 14 April 2021 in case 2-19-10324/42, the Supreme Court changed its earlier position that recoverable procedural costs, including legal costs, could exceed the claim value only in particularly complex and extensive cases.

The Supreme Court's revised approach

It is not justified to tie the reimbursement ceiling to the value of the civil claim. Cost rules should not make professional representation economically unreasonable and thereby render access to court illusory. Limiting reimbursement to the claim value may fail to cover even minimally necessary legal assistance and unreasonably restrict judicial protection.

What must the court consider?

Assessing whether contractual representation costs are justified and necessary under section 175(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure is a discretionary decision. The court should consider time spent, the circumstances, complexity and extent of the dispute, and the content and length of procedural documents.


For advice or a proposal for legal support, contact us through social media, our website or by phone: +372 6720 070.

Sources:
Court decision
Code of Civil Procedure, section 175(1)

MAGILEX← Back to all articles